Sling vs. When I Work: A Comprehensive Comparison

If you’re looking for an employee scheduling tool for your business, you’ll likely come across Sling and When I Work. Both apps offer key features that help you oversee your labor force and save time on tasks like shift scheduling and payroll.

Here are the critical differences between Sling and When I Work.

  • Sling offers a free plan with minimal features
  • When I Work includes automated scheduling in its standard plan
  • Sling does not have a feature for photo clock-ins

Jump to the sections you’re most interested in, or read the entire article.

What is Sling?

Rating: 4.4 / 5.0 according to G2 customer reviews

Sling is a popular software on employee scheduling. Through Sling, administrators create schedules using drag-and-drop, color-coded templates. Organizations that sign up for the business plan can automate their scheduling processes, allowing the software to create schedules for them.

Sling also includes communication and time-tracking options. Managers and employees can communicate directly within the app through groups or direct messages. 

Team members can clock in and out for shifts using mobile devices or a designated web kiosk. Sling provides timesheets for each pay period, which you can export into your payroll system.

What is When I Work?

Rating: 4.4 / 5.0 according to G2 customer reviews

When I Work aims to be your go-to solution for employee scheduling, time tracking, and team communication. You can create employee schedules through When I Work with just one click. When I Work includes basic and advanced rule-setting, ensuring your schedules reflect your coverage needs and worker availability.

Included with When I Work are extensive team messaging tools. Employees and managers can chat directly within the app instead of relying on email or phone calls. 

Additionally, adding on the Time & Attendance option provides employers with a host of other features, like timesheet creation, clock-in and clock-out, and streamlined payroll processes through integrations.

Comparison overview

Here’s a breakdown of how Sling and When I Work compare:

SlingWhen I Work
Employee scheduling• Includes shift templates to simplify the scheduling process
• Business plan offers automated scheduling
• Create employee schedules automatically
• Optimize shifts to minimize labor expenses
Team messaging• Communicate with employees directly or through group messaging• Direct group and individual messaging included
• Read receipts
Time management• Employees can clock in for their shifts using the app
• Geofencing ensures employees are actually at the job site before allowing clock-in
• Employees can clock in and out of their shifts using the app
• Provides GPS and photo enforcement options
Pricing• Free for basic employee scheduling; paid options start at $1.70 per user for annual plansStarts at $2.50 per user for the Essentials plan


GetSling vs. When I Work: Key features

Understanding the key features between Sling and When I Work helps you determine which app is right for your business.

Sling

Sling offers the following key features:

  • Employee scheduling
  • Direct messaging within the app
  • Clock in and out with geofencing capabilities
  • Free plan available for basic scheduling needs

When I Work

When I Work includes the following essential features:

  • Automatic, rules-based employee scheduling
  • One-on-one and group messaging
  • Advanced clock-in and out options, including GPS and photo enforcement
  • The Essentials plan starts at $2.50 per user

Employee scheduling

Employee scheduling is the bread and butter of both Sling and When I Work. It is often a major headache for shift-based companies like restaurants, retail stores, and hospitals. Managers can save time and money with the help of either app.

Sling

Sling minimizes the time spent on employee scheduling with the help of shift templates. Once they create an optimal template, they simply roll it over to the next week and make any necessary adjustments to their new schedule. Employees can submit time-off requests through the app, and managers can share available shifts.

When I Work

When I Work is easy to use and automates the employee scheduling process with the help of basic and advanced rule-setting. You can create and copy and paste templates or use Auto Scheduling with one click. Once the app understands your coverage needs and employee availability, it will create weekly schedules for you. You’ll review the schedule and make any changes before sharing it with your team. 

Team messaging

Team communication is often challenging for businesses, especially when employees work at different times and locations. Both Sling and When I Work include options for team messaging.

Sling

Under Sling’s free plan, you can share news and company announcements with your team. Upgrading to a premium or business plan lets you contact team members directly or create group chats. You’ll keep all your messages in one place.

When I Work

When I Work offers the same comprehensive communication features in all plans. You can create different channels for group chats or message individual team members. All messages are saved within the app, so you can refer to them later if needed. You can also see who has read the message and when.

Time management

Keeping track of your employee’s comings and goings is a major hassle, especially for companies with multiple shifts or job sites. Both Sling and When I Work provide features to limit your workload and monitor employee time.

Sling

Through Sling, employees can clock in and out for work through their mobile devices. They’ll receive reminders before their shift starts, helping ensure they don’t forget to check in. 

Sling includes a few extra features to ensure you pay employees only for their time on the job, like early clock-in prevention and auto clock-out. Additionally, you can enable geofencing, which prevents employees from clocking in if they’re not at their designated work location. 

When I Work

Upgrading to the When I Work Time & Attendance module gives you access to robust time clock features. Employees can clock in and out for their shifts via their smartphones. Web and terminal time clocks are also available. 

When I Work includes GPS enforcement, preventing employees from clocking in if they’re not actually at work. Additionally, you can ask employees to take a photo of themselves when they arrive for extra protection against buddy punching.

Pricing

While employee scheduling, team messaging, and time clock management are essential to most businesses, you want to keep a firm grasp on your costs. Both When I Work and Sling offer competitive pricing alternatives.

Sling

Sling is one of the only employee scheduling apps that offers an entirely free plan option. While the free plan provides minimal features, it’s helpful for small businesses that simply want a scheduling option. 

Upgrading to the premium and business plans will give you access to messaging and time clock options. Premium starts at $1.70 per user, and business plans are $3.40 per user under an annual subscription.  

When I Work

When I Work offers three pricing plans—Essentials, Pro, and Premium. The Essentials Plan starts at $2.50 per user, Pro is $5.00 per user, and Premium is $8.00 per user. 

If you need time management and payroll options, you can add Time & Attendance. With Time & Attendance, monthly prices increase to $4.00 per user for the Essentials Plan, $7.00 per user for the Pro Plan, and $10.00 per user for the Premium Plan.

Sling vs. When I Work: Which is best for you?

Deciding between Sling and When I Work depends on your company’s needs. For a relatively small organization that doesn’t require advanced scheduling assistance, Sling is the cheaper option that may fulfill your requirements. 

However, organizations with more than ten employees on rotating shifts will likely find When I Work more effective. Since When I Work entirely automates employee scheduling, you’ll probably see more time savings.

When I Work: Best for scheduling needs

When I Work offers a robust platform for employee scheduling and time management that can help small businesses save time, get better shift coverage, and control labor costs. To learn more about employee scheduling with When I Work, you can schedule a demo or sign up for a fully-featured 14-day free trial today.

FAQs

What is a good work schedule app?

Several employee scheduling apps are on the market, including Sling and When I Work. It’s best to compare your scheduling needs with the app’s features to decide which is appropriate for your company.

Is Sling employee scheduling really free?

Sling offers a free plan, but it contains minimal features. You can create employee schedules and save your templates through the free option. However, the free plan does not include time clock options and limits messaging to announcements and company news.

How much does Sling business cost?

Monthly subscribers to Sling business pay $4.00 per user.

Article Image
/Human Resources

Employee Burnout: Causes, Signs, And Strategies

Article Image
/Business Growth

9 Strategies For Decreasing Labor Costs

Article Image
/Scheduling Strategy

Rotating Shifts: A Manager’s Guide to Rotating Schedules

Article Image
/Scheduling Strategy

How to Save Time And Money With Automatic Scheduling For Employees

Article Image
/Small Business Blog

40 Employee Appreciation Ideas Your Staff Will Love

Article Image
/Human Resources

How to Write Up an Employee in 8 Easy Steps